Which Juicy bag would you go with?

I would go for the second one, the NEW SCOTTIE EMBROIDERY DAYDREAMER BAG. Personally I can't stand little rhinestones on my bags, and I think just plain with the logo is enough. The first one draws too much attention, it doesn't work too well. But the second one has that nice iconic Juicy Couture touch and even though there's a bedazzled charm hanging on the side, you can remove it, so that's a nice bonus for a more subtle handbag.